| Some
have raised the question of
Chang San Feng's existence as
there is much legendary material
about him. He is recorded by
reliable historical documents
such as the 'Ming History' and
'The Ningpo Chronicles' which
have no relation to martial
arts literature as having existed
and to have created Wudang Internal
Boxing arts. This is in line
with the beliefs held at the
Wudang Temple itself and one
can find much old material pertaining
to Chang San Feng there. According
to the available material, Chang
lived at the end of the Yuan
Dynasty (1279-1368) and at the
beginning of the Ming Dynasty
(1368-1644). There was a confusion
of dates as the Emperor Yung
Ler used searching for Chang
as an excuse to send Yan Wang
Chu in 1403 to scoure the country
in search of his rival, the
Emperor Jian Wen. Chang San
Feng was widely regarded as
a Taoist saint and Emperor Yung
Ler knew that he had already
died and so came up with the
ruse. Historians who have tried
to reconcile the misinformation
of the Emperor Yung Le with
the earlier records have either
regarded Chang as a mid Ming
Dynasty personage, possibly
a different person from the
Chang San Feng of recorded as
living in the Yuan Dynasty or
that Chang had lived for a very
long time, beyond normal human
life expectancy.
The Zhao Bao style of Taijiquan
also traces their art back to
Jiang Fa and Wang Tsung Yueh
and ultimately to Chang San
Feng. Gu Liu Xin, the noted
Taijiquan historian, posits
based on the writings of Chen
Xin that Chen Ching Ping created
the Zhao Bao style. Chen Ching
Ping was a student of Chen You
Pen who created the `new frame'
(xin jia) of Chen Taijiquan
which was also known as the
`high frame' (gao jia) and `small
frame' (xiao jia). Chen Qing
Ping was also recorded to be
a student of the Zhao Bao Taijiquan
master Zhang Yan. Wu Yu Xiang
who learnt from Chen Ching Ping
retained this high standing
characteristic in the style
he passed down.
The present Zhao Bao style is
relatively low standing and
is performed in a slow manner
without fa-jing (strength emissions)
except in kicks, in a manner
common to the Yang and Wu Yu
Xiang styles and those that
developed from them.
This theory can not be reliably
proven, all that we can ascertain
is that the art came down from
Wang Tsung Yueh and Jiang Fa
to the Chen village and Zhao
Bao villiage. It is unlikely
that Chang developed Taijiquan
as we see it today though he
may have invented some of the
principles that went into the
art. The works attributed to
him in the Taijiquan Classics
are actually the works of Wang
Tsung Yueh. This is evident
in the handwritten manuals of
Li I Yu.
The Chen Pu Theory
This was the theory put out
by Chen Xin, the first to write
a book on the Chen style of
Taijiquan. He attributed the
creation of the art to Chen
Pu, this was echoed later by
Chen Ji Pu in his later book
on the art. Chen Xin records
that Chen Pu taught his descendents
a way to digest food, and Chen
Xin claims this to be Taijiquan.
Chen Pu's grave has nothing
to indicate that he was skilled
in martial arts or to have created
Taijiquan, a very significant
piece of evidence since the
Chen Family was famous for its
boxing for genrations, gaining
the name `Pao Chui Chen Family'.
So this theory has been proven
to be false.
The Chen Wang Ting Theory
This theory was first posited
by Tang Hao. He based his theory
on the side note in the Chen
Family Manual (Chen Si Jia Pu)
that Chen Wang Ting (1597-1664)
was the creator of the Chen
Fist, broadsword and spear arts,
and on the assumption that the
Chen family did not learn arts
from outside the Chen family.
According to the Annals Of Wen
County, Chen Wang Ting served
as an officer in Shantung Province
from 1618 to 1621 and was officer
in charge of the garrison at
Wen County in 1641.
The theory was further elaborated
upon by Gu Liu Xin, Tang Hao's
good friend. He brought in a
poem attributed to Chen Wang
Ting that stated that Chen Wang
Ting `created boxing when bored'
and a Boxing Song Formula attributed
to Chen Wang Ting as proof of
the theory. Modern linguistic
studies show that it should
actually be translated as 'no
bored (free) time to create
boxing' instead.
We need to note that the references
to boxing in the Chen Family
are in the side notes and are
not in the main text. Since
the Chen family was famous for
its boxing, it seems a gross
ommission that such an important
article of information as Chen
Wang Ting creating the Chen
family arts is not included
in the main text but is in a
side note. What more, the earliest
published works by the Chen
family on their art does not
attribute the creation of the
art to Chen Wang Ting. The last
line of the Chen Family Manual
says clearly that the side notes
were the work of Chen Xin and
so it is a recently added reference.
Yet Chen Xin does not posit
that Chen Wang Ting is the creator,
but instead Chen Pu.
(1)(2)(3)(4) |